Best Pizza in New York City
Independent FoodIndex rankings for pizza in New York City.
Top rated pizza restaurants
-
-
#2
Joe’s Pizza
Classic SliceFamily-owned since 1964, famous for their classic New York-style slices.
124 Fulton St · Financial District
FoodIndex Score 87.99View -
#3
Burchak Pide
Classic SliceGreenwich Village institution offering the quintessential New York slice.
1614 Sheepshead Bay Rd · Sheepshead Bay
FoodIndex Score 87.88View -
-
#5
NY Pizza Suprema
Turkish-StyleTurkish-style flatbread pizzas with unique Mediterranean flavors and spices.
413 8th Ave · Chelsea
FoodIndex Score 87.49View -
#6
Mano's Pizzeria
Classic SliceQueens neighborhood favorite serving hearty pizzas with generous toppings.
62-98 Forest Ave · Ridgewood
FoodIndex Score 87.38View -
#7
Fumo Harlem
Wood-FiredWood-fired pizzas with smoky flavor and perfectly charred crusts.
1600 Amsterdam Ave · Harlem
FoodIndex Score 87.36View -
#8
Joe's Pizza
Classic SliceStaten Island gem delivering classic pies with fresh, quality ingredients.
1435 Broadway · Midtown
FoodIndex Score 87.22View -
-
-
#11
Denino’s Pizzeria
Thin CrustStaten Island institution famous for their thin-crust pies since 1937.
524 Port Richmond Ave · Port Richmond
FoodIndex Score 86.62View -
#12
SIMÒ PIZZA
NeapolitanAuthentic Neapolitan pizzeria with imported Italian ingredients and VPN certification.
90-92 Gansevoort St · Meatpacking District
FoodIndex Score 85.75View -
#13
Bleecker Street Pizza
NeapolitanCozy spot serving Neapolitan-style pizzas with puffy, airy crusts.
69 7th Ave S · West Village
FoodIndex Score 85.67View -
#14
Song' E Napule
Wood-FiredHarlem's wood-fired pizza destination with Italian-inspired flavors.
132 W Houston St · SoHo
FoodIndex Score 85.29View -
-
#16
Santa Panza
Classic SliceMidtown spot serving reliable New York-style slices near Central Park.
1079 Broadway · Bushwick
FoodIndex Score 85.08View -
#17
Pop's Pizza
Classic SliceUpper East Side neighborhood favorite with consistently delicious pies.
301 W 57th St Ground floor · Midtown
FoodIndex Score 85.00View -
#18
Mimi's Pizza
Coal OvenCoal-fired pizzas with crispy, charred crusts and authentic Italian toppings.
217 East 86th St · Upper East Side
FoodIndex Score 84.92View -
#19
Joe's Pizza
Coal OvenEast Harlem legend serving coal oven pizzas with charred, crispy crusts since 1933.
7 Carmine St · Greenwich Village
FoodIndex Score 84.73View -
#20
Little Charli
Detroit-StyleDetroit-style square pies with creative toppings and crispy, caramelized edges.
271 Bleecker St · Greenwich Village
FoodIndex Score 84.71View -
#21
Patsy's Pizzeria
Classic SliceMidtown East pizzeria offering customizable pies with fresh toppings.
2287 1st Ave · East Harlem
FoodIndex Score 84.29View -
-
#23
My Pie Pizzeria
Classic SliceOriginal location serving legendary slices since 1975.
690 Lexington Ave · Midtown East
FoodIndex Score 84.14View -
#24
Il Miglio Brick Oven
NeapolitanAward-winning Neapolitan pizzas with soft, pillowy crusts and imported ingredients.
11-03 36th Ave · Astoria
FoodIndex Score 84.10View -
#25
Ace's Pizza
SavoryBrooklyn specialty spot blending pizza with savory beef and cheese toppings.
637 Driggs Ave · Williamsburg
FoodIndex Score 83.99View -
#26
Ungaro Coal Fired
Classic SliceWilliamsburg favorite serving New York-style slices with crispy crusts.
1298 Forest Ave · Mariners Harbor
FoodIndex Score 83.95View -
#27
Emmy Squared Pizza
Detroit-StyleWest Village hotspot known for inventive Detroit-style square pizzas.
311 W 48th St · Hell's Kitchen
FoodIndex Score 83.57View -
#28
Louie & Ernie's
Classic SliceMidtown staple offering classic Italian-American pizzas and pasta.
1300 Crosby Ave · Pelham Bay
FoodIndex Score 83.44View -
#29
El Tanque Trattoria Bar
Classic SliceWilliamsburg pizzeria serving New York-style pies in casual setting.
101 Sherman Ave Suite 3 · Inwood
FoodIndex Score 83.34View -
#30
Brooklyn Beef N’ Cheese
Wood-FiredSoho bar and pizzeria with craft cocktails and artisan wood-fired pizzas.
5409 Avenue T · Flatlands
FoodIndex Score 83.24View -
#31
Kesté Pizza e Vino
Coal OvenBronx institution serving coal oven pizzas with charred, crispy crusts since 1947.
77 Fulton St · Financial District
FoodIndex Score 83.08View -
#32
Roma Pizza
Classic SliceBrooklyn's favorite spot for classic New York-style pizza.
980 6th Ave · Midtown
FoodIndex Score 83.05View -
#33
La Pizza Italia
Whole PiesHistoric brick oven pizzeria serving whole pies only since 1929.
959 2nd Ave · Midtown East
FoodIndex Score 82.79View -
#34
Broadway Pizza
Classic SliceUpper West Side spot delivering authentic New York slices and pies.
1142 Broadway · Midtown
FoodIndex Score 82.77View -
#35
Joe's Pizza
Authentic ItalianMidtown East pizzeria with Italian classics and traditional flavors.
216 Bedford Ave · Williamsburg
FoodIndex Score 82.75View -
-
#37
LTD Pizza and Bar
Roman-StyleWest Village newcomer serving Roman-style pizza with crispy, rectangular slices.
225 Hudson St · Hudson Square
FoodIndex Score 82.47View -
#38
Alfie's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Budget-FriendlyBudget-friendly pizza chain offering fresh, affordable slices across Manhattan.
86-08 117th St · Richmond Hill
FoodIndex Score 82.34View -
#39
New Park Pizza
Classic SliceLong Island City spot serving New York-style pies with crispy crusts.
156-71 Cross Bay Blvd · Howard Beach
FoodIndex Score 82.20View -
#40
Reg'z New York Pizza
Classic SliceGreenwich Village pizzeria with creative pies and thin, crispy crusts.
28-17 36th Ave · Astoria
FoodIndex Score 82.07View -
#41
Pizza Palace
Coal OvenMidtown coal oven pizzeria delivering crispy, charred crusts since 1989.
121 Dyckman St · Inwood
FoodIndex Score 82.02View -
#42
B Side Pizza Bar
Classic SliceBronx neighborhood favorite serving generous portions and classic New York slices.
370 W 51st St · Hell's Kitchen
FoodIndex Score 81.92View -
#43
GoodFellas Pizzeria of
Square PiesHoward Beach institution famous for square pies with crispy, thick crusts.
25-19 40th Ave · Sunnyside
FoodIndex Score 81.81View -
#44
Krunchy Krust Pizza & Wings
Wood-FiredHell's Kitchen bar and pizzeria with craft beers and wood-fired pizzas.
221-15 Linden Blvd · Cambria Heights
FoodIndex Score 81.45View -
#45
Carnegie Pizza
Wood-FiredRidgewood pizzeria offering wood-fired Neapolitan pies with blistered crusts.
200 W 41st St · Midtown
FoodIndex Score 81.23View -
#46
$1.50 Fresh Pizza
Classic SliceRichmond Hill family spot serving classic pies with New York-style crusts.
1723 Broadway · Midtown
FoodIndex Score 81.18View -
#47
Made In New York
Classic SliceAstoria pizzeria delivering authentic New York-style slices and pies.
421 Amsterdam Ave · Upper West Side
FoodIndex Score 81.13View -
#48
Singas Famous Pizza
Brick OvenStaten Island favorite known for brick oven pizzas with crispy crusts.
2841 Grand Concourse · Fordham
FoodIndex Score 80.99View -
#49
Leonardo’s Pizza
NeapolitanFinancial District gem serving Neapolitan pizzas with soft, chewy crusts.
41-10 49th St · Sunnyside
FoodIndex Score 80.92View -
#50
Margherita Pizza
KosherFlushing kosher pizzeria offering certified kosher pies and Middle Eastern toppings.
163-04 Jamaica Ave · Jamaica
FoodIndex Score 80.68View -
-
#52
Philomena's Pizza
Classic SliceQueens neighborhood spot serving classic margherita and traditional pies.
41-16 Queens Blvd · Sunnyside
FoodIndex Score 80.56View -
#53
Lee's Tavern
Thin CrustStaten Island tavern famous for their thin-crust bar pies since 1980.
60 Hancock St · Dongan Hills
FoodIndex Score 80.51View -
#54
Patricia's Pizza of Tremont
Classic SliceBushwick neighborhood staple delivering classic New York slices.
3883 E Tremont Ave · Throgs Neck
FoodIndex Score 80.44View -
#55
La Vera Pizzeria
Classic SliceInwood favorite serving reliable pies with generous cheese and toppings.
2071 Clove Rd · Sunnyside
FoodIndex Score 80.43View -
#56
Goodfella's
NeapolitanMidtown pizzeria with Neapolitan-style pies and soft, pillowy crusts.
4029 Hylan Blvd · Great Kills
FoodIndex Score 80.33View -
#57
Artistic Pizza
Classic SliceStaten Island pizzeria offering Brooklyn-style pies with thick, doughy crusts.
123 W 3rd St · Greenwich Village
FoodIndex Score 79.83View -
#58
Traditas Pizza
NeapolitanHell's Kitchen spot serving Neapolitan-style pizzas with authentic Italian flavor.
83 Maiden Ln · Financial District
FoodIndex Score 79.79View -
#59
Saraghina Pizzeria
SicilianGreenwich Village pizzeria known for Sicilian-style thick, square pies.
350 Lewis Ave · Bedford-Stuyvesant
FoodIndex Score 79.66View -
#60
Gravesend Pizza
Classic SliceBronx neighborhood favorite delivering classic New York slices since 1989.
181 34th St · Sunset Park
FoodIndex Score 79.58View -
#61
Tony's Pizza
Classic SliceManhattan pizzeria chain offering consistent New York-style pies.
443 Knickerbocker Ave · Bushwick
FoodIndex Score 79.56View -
#62
The Astarita
Classic SliceQueens family-run pizzeria serving traditional pies with homemade taste.
797 5th Ave · Bay Ridge
FoodIndex Score 79.54View -
#63
Ledo Pizza
Jumbo SlicesColumbia University area legend famous for their massive jumbo slices.
243 W 38th St · Garment District
FoodIndex Score 79.52View -
#64
Underground Pizza
Coal OvenHell's Kitchen pizzeria offering coal-fired pies with crispy, charred crusts.
3 Hanover Square #2615 · Financial District
FoodIndex Score 79.49View -
#65
Naomi's Kosher Pizza & Falafel
Budget-FriendlyBudget-friendly pizza chain offering fresh, affordable slices across Manhattan.
68-28 Main St · Flushing
FoodIndex Score 79.13View -
#66
Pugsley Pizza
SicilianFinancial District favorite serving square Sicilian-style pies with thick crusts.
590 E 191st St · Fordham
FoodIndex Score 79.11View -
#67
Dani's House of Pizza
Classic SliceSunnyside neighborhood spot delivering classic New York pies.
81-28 Lefferts Blvd · Kew Gardens
FoodIndex Score 79.09View -
#68
Patrizia's of Brooklyn
Classic SliceBrooklyn pizzeria offering traditional pies with thin, crispy crusts.
4255 Amboy Rd · Tottenville
FoodIndex Score 78.94View -
#69
LaVista Pizza
Budget-FriendlyBudget-friendly Manhattan chain serving quick, affordable dollar slices.
730 10th Ave · Hell's Kitchen
FoodIndex Score 78.89View -
#70
Joe & Sal's Pizza
Classic SliceManhattan pizzeria chain offering consistent New York-style pies.
842 Franklin Ave · Crown Heights
FoodIndex Score 78.83View -
#71
Sacco Pizza
HalalQueens halal pizzeria offering certified halal pies with flavorful toppings.
819 9th Ave · Hell's Kitchen
FoodIndex Score 78.78View -
#72
Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria
Classic SliceFinancial District pizzeria serving traditional New York-style slices.
117 W 57th St · Midtown
FoodIndex Score 78.57View -
#73
$1.50 Fresh Pizza
NeapolitanMidtown pizzeria by renowned chef offering authentic Neapolitan pies with soft crusts.
473 Lexington Ave · Midtown East
FoodIndex Score 78.17View -
-
-
#76
Koronet Pizza
Wood-FiredBed-Stuy pizzeria featuring wood-fired Neapolitan pies with blistered crusts.
2848 Broadway · Morningside Heights
FoodIndex Score 77.71View -
#77
LaVista Pizza
Coal OvenBay Ridge coal oven pizzeria delivering authentic Southern Italian flavors and charred crusts.
1099 2nd Ave · Midtown East
FoodIndex Score 77.58View -
-
-
#80
Rosa's Pizza
Classic SliceTimes Square pizzeria serving quick, reliable New York-style slices.
55-26 69th St · Maspeth
FoodIndex Score 77.13View -
#81
Adrienne's Pizzabar
Classic SliceRego Park neighborhood spot delivering classic New York pies.
54 Stone St · Financial District
FoodIndex Score 76.90View -
#82
Don Antonio's Pizza
Thin CrustProspect Heights favorite serving thin-crust pizzas with crispy texture.
309 W 50th St · Hell's Kitchen
FoodIndex Score 76.81View -
#83
$1.50 Fresh Pizza
Vegan OptionsWilliamsburg late-night spot famous for creative vegan slices and traditional options.
151 E 43rd St · Midtown East
FoodIndex Score 76.49View -
-
#85
Vinnie's Pizzeria
Classic SliceBronx neighborhood institution serving classic New York pies since 1994.
148 Bedford Ave · Williamsburg
FoodIndex Score 76.34View -
-
#87
The Pie Guy Pizza
Budget-FriendlyBudget-friendly pizza chain offering fresh, affordable slices across Manhattan.
83-85 Baxter St · Chinatown
FoodIndex Score 75.87View -
#88
2 Bros Pizza
Classic SliceStaten Island family pizzeria offering classic pies with traditional recipes.
557 8th Ave · Midtown
FoodIndex Score 75.80View -
#89
Champion Pizza
Classic SliceGreenwich Village pizzeria serving reliable New York-style slices.
61-35 Junction Blvd · Corona
FoodIndex Score 75.69View -
#90
Tutto Apposto Cucina Italiana
Coal OvenBay Ridge pizzeria delivering coal-fired pies with crispy, thin crusts.
31 Page Ave · Tottenville
FoodIndex Score 75.52View -
#91
Tommy's Pizza
Classic SliceEast Harlem neighborhood spot serving classic New York-style slices.
4033 E Tremont Ave · Throgs Neck
FoodIndex Score 75.38View -
#92
Percy's Pizza
Classic SliceBronx pizzeria offering traditional pies with generous toppings.
190 Bleecker St · Greenwich Village
FoodIndex Score 75.33View -
#93
Original Pizza
Brick OvenStaten Island Italian restaurant featuring brick oven pizzas with authentic flavor.
2351 Ralph Ave · Canarsie
FoodIndex Score 75.30View -
#94
Uncle Paul's Pizza
Classic SliceQueens neighborhood favorite serving generous portions and classic slices.
70 Vanderbilt Ave · Fort Greene
FoodIndex Score 75.21View -
#95
Royal Pizza
Authentic ItalianStaten Island spot offering authentic Italian pizzas with traditional recipes.
1757 Arthur Kill Rd · Richmond Valley
FoodIndex Score 74.72View -
#96
Brother's Pizzeria
Classic SliceBrooklyn family pizzeria serving classic New York pies for over three decades.
750 Port Richmond Ave · Port Richmond
FoodIndex Score 74.68View -
#97
Gaby's Pizza
Square PiesChinatown pizzeria delivering unique square pies with creative toppings.
204-23 Hillside Ave. · Hollis
FoodIndex Score 72.71View -
#98
La Villa Pizzeria
Classic SliceStaten Island neighborhood spot offering reliable New York-style pizzas.
6610 Avenue U · Gravesend
FoodIndex Score 70.19View -
#99
Cento Uno Pizzeria
Classic SliceBrooklyn pizzeria serving traditional Italian pies with fresh ingredients.
3101 Quentin Rd · Sheepshead Bay
FoodIndex Score 65.51View
No restaurants match your search.