Skip to content

Best Pizza in Bay Ridge

Showing 3 of 3 restaurants · Ranked by FoodIndex score

Top pizza in Bay Ridge, New York City.

Top pizza in Bay Ridge

  1. #1

    Mancini

    Brick Oven

    Brick oven pizzeria with authentic Italian food and freshly handmade pastas.

    8504 5th Ave · Bay Ridge

    Google: 4.6 Yelp: 4.4 Uber Eats: 4.8

    FoodIndex Score 87.81
    View
  2. #2

    The Astarita

    Classic Slice

    Queens family-run pizzeria serving traditional pies with homemade taste.

    797 5th Ave · Bay Ridge

    Google: 4.8 Yelp: 4.8 Uber Eats: —

    FoodIndex Score 79.54
    View
  3. #3

    Campania

    Classic Slice

    Bronx chain location offering consistent New York-style pies.

    9824 4th Ave · Bay Ridge

    Google: 4.6 Yelp: 4.2 Uber Eats: —

    FoodIndex Score 77.82
    View

Showing 3 of 3 by FoodIndex Score.

Explore more

More rankings, collections, and guides.

Best Pizza in other cities

More pizza nearby

Other foods in New York City

How FoodIndex rankings work

FAQs

What is the best pizza in Bay Ridge?
This page ranks pizza venues in Bay Ridge by FoodIndex Score. See the #1 listing above for the current leader.
How is this different from best pizza in New York City?
The city page covers all of New York City. This page only includes Bay Ridge venues for a more local shortlist.
Where else should I look for pizza near Bay Ridge?
Check nearby neighborhood rankings and the full Best Pizza in New York City list linked below.