Best Pizza in Midtown

Top pizza in Midtown

1. #1

   Joe's Pizza

   Classic Slice

   Staten Island gem delivering classic pies with fresh, quality ingredients.

   1435 Broadway · Midtown

   Google: 4.5 | Yelp: 4.2 | Uber Eats: 4.6

   FoodIndex Score 87.22

   View +Compare ✓Selected
2. #2

   Pop's Pizza

   Classic Slice

   Upper East Side neighborhood favorite with consistently delicious pies.

   301 W 57th St Ground floor · Midtown

   Google: 4.8 | Yelp: 4.5 | Uber Eats: 4.7

   FoodIndex Score 85.00

   View +Compare ✓Selected
3. #3

   Roma Pizza

   Classic Slice

   Brooklyn's favorite spot for classic New York-style pizza.

   980 6th Ave · Midtown

   Google: 4.7 | Yelp: 4.4 | Uber Eats: 4.7

   FoodIndex Score 83.05

   View +Compare ✓Selected
4. #4

   Broadway Pizza

   Classic Slice

   Upper West Side spot delivering authentic New York slices and pies.

   1142 Broadway · Midtown

   Google: 4.7 | Yelp: 4.4 | Uber Eats: 4.6

   FoodIndex Score 82.77

   View +Compare ✓Selected
5. #5

   Carnegie Pizza

   Wood-Fired

   Ridgewood pizzeria offering wood-fired Neapolitan pies with blistered crusts.

   200 W 41st St · Midtown

   Google: 4.6 | Yelp: 4.5 | Uber Eats: 4.2

   FoodIndex Score 81.23

   View +Compare ✓Selected
6. #6

   $1.50 Fresh Pizza

   Classic Slice

   Richmond Hill family spot serving classic pies with New York-style crusts.

   1723 Broadway · Midtown

   Google: 4.5 | Yelp: 3.9 | Uber Eats: 4.7

   FoodIndex Score 81.18

   View +Compare ✓Selected
7. #7

   Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

   Classic Slice

   Financial District pizzeria serving traditional New York-style slices.

   117 W 57th St · Midtown

   Google: 4.4 | Yelp: 4.0 | Uber Eats: 4.4

   FoodIndex Score 78.57

   View +Compare ✓Selected
8. #8

   PizzArte

   Classic Slice

   Crown Heights neighborhood favorite serving New York-style slices.

   69 W 55th St · Midtown

   Google: 4.5 | Yelp: 4.1 | Uber Eats: 4.2

   FoodIndex Score 77.39

   View +Compare ✓Selected
9. #9

   2 Bros Pizza

   Classic Slice

   Staten Island family pizzeria offering classic pies with traditional recipes.

   557 8th Ave · Midtown

   Google: 4.3 | Yelp: 3.7 | Uber Eats: 4.4

   FoodIndex Score 75.80

   View +Compare ✓Selected

No restaurants match your search.