Skip to content

Pizza · New York City · Upper West Side

Made In New York

Google 4.6 (1203) Yelp 4.3 (635) Uber Eats 4.6 (600) $$ 81.13 FoodIndex

Astoria pizzeria delivering authentic New York-style slices and pies. Read more

Made In New York
Website Call Directions Order online Suggest update

Featured In

Not currently featured in an indexable ranking, collection, or guide.

About

Located at 421 Amsterdam Ave in Upper West Side, Made In New York is astoria pizzeria delivering authentic New York-style slices and pies, earning it a place among Manhattan's top destinations for authentic classic slice pizza. Set in the heart of Upper West Side, Manhattan, it has become a favorite for anyone hunting the best pizza in Upper West Side and beyond. Those hunting the best pizza in Upper West Side will find the menu compelling, with highlights including Cheese Pie, Pepperoni Pie, Margherita Pie, and Vodka Pie. See how it stacks up on Google, Yelp, and Uber Eats and check the FoodIndex score on this page alongside the full menu.

Known for: Astoria pizzeria delivering authentic New York-style slices and pies.

Made In New York Reviews

Curious how diners rate Made In New York? This page pulls public review signals from Google, Yelp, and Uber Eats so you can compare platforms in one place. Scores below reflect diner feedback for this pizza spot in Upper West Side, New York City.

On Google 4.6 from 1200+ reviews, Yelp 4.3 from 630+ reviews, and Uber Eats 4.6 from 600+ reviews. FoodIndex combines those multi-platform signals into a single FoodIndex Score of 81.13 for Made In New York. The score rewards consistent quality across platforms, not paid placement.

Made In New York Menu

Cheese Pie

Cheese Pie

$27.00

Pepperoni Pie

Pepperoni Pie

$32.00

Margherita Pie

Margherita Pie

$32.00

Vodka Pie

Vodka Pie

$32.00

Sausage Pie

Sausage Pie

$32.00

Gluten Free Pie

Gluten Free Pie

$19.00

Buffalo Chicken Pie

Buffalo Chicken Pie

$37.00

BBQ Chicken Pie

BBQ Chicken Pie

$37.00

Mushroom Pie

Mushroom Pie

$32.00

Sausage Jalapeno Pie

Sausage Jalapeno Pie

$37.00

Amenities & attributes

  • Onsite services available
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Outdoor seating
  • No-contact delivery
  • Delivery
  • Onsite services
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in
  • Fast service
  • Serves local specialty
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining
  • Alcohol
  • Beer
  • Comfort food
  • Late-night food
  • Quick bite
  • Vegetarian options
  • Wine
  • Catering
  • Counter service
  • Dessert
  • Seating
  • Table service
  • Restroom
  • Casual
  • Cozy
  • Trendy
  • College students
  • Tourists
  • Accepts reservations
  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Good for kids
  • Paid parking garage
  • Paid street parking
  • Usually difficult to find a space

Location & hours

421 Amsterdam Ave, Upper West Side, New York

Get directions

Similar

Nearby

Browse nearby

Pizza Burgers Coffee Sushi Steaks Seafood Tacos Bakery Hot Dogs

FAQs

What is Made In New York's FoodIndex Score?
Made In New York currently scores 81.13 on FoodIndex, based on Google, Yelp, and Uber Eats rating signals.
Where is Made In New York?
Made In New York is at 421 Amsterdam Ave, Upper West Side, New York.
Does Made In New York have a menu on FoodIndex?
Yes. See the Made In New York Menu section on this page for dishes, prices, and photos when available.
Where do Made In New York reviews come from?
FoodIndex shows Google, Yelp, and Uber Eats rating signals for Made In New York when data is available, then combines them into the FoodIndex Score. See the Reviews section on this page for platform ratings and review volume.