Best Pizza in Midtown East

Top pizza in Midtown East

1. #1

   My Pie Pizzeria

   Classic Slice

   Original location serving legendary slices since 1975.

   690 Lexington Ave · Midtown East

   Google: 4.7 | Yelp: 4.4 | Uber Eats: 4.7

   FoodIndex Score 84.14

   View +Compare ✓Selected
2. #2

   La Pizza Italia

   Whole Pies

   Historic brick oven pizzeria serving whole pies only since 1929.

   959 2nd Ave · Midtown East

   Google: 4.8 | Yelp: 4.2 | Uber Eats: 4.5

   FoodIndex Score 82.79

   View +Compare ✓Selected
3. #3

   $1.50 Fresh Pizza

   Neapolitan

   Midtown pizzeria by renowned chef offering authentic Neapolitan pies with soft crusts.

   473 Lexington Ave · Midtown East

   Google: 4.5 | Yelp: 3.8 | Uber Eats: 4.6

   FoodIndex Score 78.17

   View +Compare ✓Selected
4. #4

   LaVista Pizza

   Coal Oven

   Bay Ridge coal oven pizzeria delivering authentic Southern Italian flavors and charred crusts.

   1099 2nd Ave · Midtown East

   Google: 4.8 | Yelp: 3.9 | Uber Eats: 4.4

   FoodIndex Score 77.58

   View +Compare ✓Selected
5. #5

   $1.50 Fresh Pizza

   Vegan Options

   Williamsburg late-night spot famous for creative vegan slices and traditional options.

   151 E 43rd St · Midtown East

   Google: 4.5 | Yelp: 3.9 | Uber Eats: —

   FoodIndex Score 76.49

   View +Compare ✓Selected

No restaurants match your search.