Skip to content

Seafood · New York City · Harlem

Make My Fish

Google 4.5 (730) Yelp 4.2 (186) Uber Eats 4.7 (6000) $$ 87.14 FoodIndex

Custom seafood spot where you choose your fish and cooking style. Read more

Make My Fish
Make My Fish photo 2
Make My Fish photo 3
Website Call Directions Order online Suggest update

Featured In

About

Make My Fish at 120 W 116th St in Harlem is custom seafood spot where you choose your fish and cooking style, making it one of Manhattan's most respected spots for authentic custom seafood. Nestled in Harlem, Manhattan, it draws locals and visitors who seek out the best seafood in Harlem and across New York. If you are searching for great seafood in Harlem, the menu featuring Fish & Shrimp Dinner, Catfish and Shrimp Combo(with Fries), All Fish, and Shrimp and Fish Combo (incl Fries) gives you every reason to visit. Compare its Google, Yelp, and Uber Eats ratings alongside the FoodIndex score and browse the full menu on this page.

Known for: Custom seafood spot where you choose your fish and cooking style.

Make My Fish Reviews

Curious how diners rate Make My Fish? This page pulls public review signals from Google, Yelp, and Uber Eats so you can compare platforms in one place. Scores below reflect diner feedback for this seafood spot in Harlem, New York City.

On Google 4.5 from 730+ reviews, Yelp 4.2 from 180+ reviews, and Uber Eats 4.7 from 6000+ reviews. FoodIndex combines those multi-platform signals into a single FoodIndex Score of 87.14 for Make My Fish. The score rewards consistent quality across platforms, not paid placement.

Make My Fish Menu

Fish & Shrimp Dinner

Fish & Shrimp Dinner

$26.00

Catfish and Shrimp Combo(with Fries)

Catfish and Shrimp Combo(with Fries)

$24.00

All Fish

All Fish

$13.00

Shrimp and Fish Combo (incl Fries)

Shrimp and Fish Combo (incl Fries)

$22.50

Shrimp and Fish Combo with fries

Shrimp and Fish Combo with fries

$22.50

All Catfish

All Catfish

$15.00

Chicken Dinner

Chicken Dinner

$19.50

Macaroni and Cheese

Macaroni and Cheese

$6.50

Shrimp and Chips

Shrimp and Chips

$16.50

Fish Sandwich

Fish Sandwich

$11.00

Amenities & attributes

  • Onsite services available
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible seating
  • Delivery
  • Onsite services
  • Takeout
  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Comfort food
  • Quick bite
  • Small plates
  • Catering
  • Counter service
  • Dessert
  • Table service
  • Restroom
  • Casual
  • Trendy
  • Family-friendly
  • Tourists
  • Usually a wait
  • Accepts reservations
  • Cash-only
  • Good for kids
  • Free street parking
  • Paid street parking
  • Usually difficult to find a space

Location & hours

120 W 116th St, Harlem, New York

Get directions

Similar

Nearby

Browse nearby

Pizza Burgers Coffee Sushi Steaks Seafood Tacos Bakery Hot Dogs

FAQs

What is Make My Fish's FoodIndex Score?
Make My Fish currently scores 87.14 on FoodIndex, based on Google, Yelp, and Uber Eats rating signals.
Where is Make My Fish?
Make My Fish is at 120 W 116th St, Harlem, New York.
Does Make My Fish have a menu on FoodIndex?
Yes. See the Make My Fish Menu section on this page for dishes, prices, and photos when available.
Where do Make My Fish reviews come from?
FoodIndex shows Google, Yelp, and Uber Eats rating signals for Make My Fish when data is available, then combines them into the FoodIndex Score. See the Reviews section on this page for platform ratings and review volume.