Best Seafood in City Island

Top seafood in City Island

1. #1

   Johnny's Reef

   Fried Seafood

   No-frills spot for fried fish, shrimp baskets, and seafood platters.

   2 City Island Ave · City Island

   Google: 4.4 | Yelp: 3.9 | Uber Eats: 3.9

   FoodIndex Score 82.00

   View +Compare ✓Selected
2. #2

   Sammy's Fish Box

   Crab Legs

   Quick-service spot for Alaskan king crab legs and seafood boils.

   41 City Island Ave · City Island

   Google: 4.3 | Yelp: 3.1 | Uber Eats: 4.4

   FoodIndex Score 73.82

   View +Compare ✓Selected
3. #3

   The Original Crab Shanty

   Grilled Fish

   Greek seafood taverna with grilled whole fish and Mediterranean plates.

   361 City Island Ave · City Island

   Google: 4.3 | Yelp: 3.6 | Uber Eats: 4.7

   FoodIndex Score 73.78

   View +Compare ✓Selected
4. #4

   Tony's Pier

   Fish Market

   Greek seafood market and grill with whole fish by the pound.

   1 City Island Ave · City Island

   Google: 4.3 | Yelp: 3.3 | Uber Eats: —

   FoodIndex Score 72.21

   View +Compare ✓Selected
5. #5

   Sammy's Smokehouse

   Latin Seafood

   Latin seafood spot with fried fish and shellfish combos.

   64 City Island Ave · City Island

   Google: 4.2 | Yelp: 3.6 | Uber Eats: —

   FoodIndex Score 71.32

   View +Compare ✓Selected
6. #6

   Seafood City

   Fish Market

   Seafood market and kitchen with fresh fish and prepared dishes.

   459 City Island Ave · City Island

   Google: 4.2 | Yelp: 3.0 | Uber Eats: —

   FoodIndex Score 69.59

   View +Compare ✓Selected

No restaurants match your search.