Best Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay, New York City

Top Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

Up to 25 venues across all foods, ranked by FoodIndex Score.

1. #1

   Burchak Pide

   Classic Slice

   Greenwich Village institution offering the quintessential New York slice.

   1614 Sheepshead Bay Rd · Sheepshead Bay

   Google: 4.8 | Yelp: 4.7 | Uber Eats: 4.9

   FoodIndex Score 87.88

   View +Compare ✓Selected
2. #2

   Shepherd's Cup

   Bold Brew

   Diner-style café known for hearty plates and strong drip coffee.

   2123 Avenue U · Sheepshead Bay

   Google: 4.8 | Yelp: 4.5 | Uber Eats: 4.8

   FoodIndex Score 84.23

   View +Compare ✓Selected
3. #3

   Orso Coffee

   Smoothie Bar

   Tropical-themed café blending fruit smoothies and iced coffee drinks.

   1745 Sheepshead Bay Rd · Sheepshead Bay

   Google: 4.5 | Yelp: 4.2 | Uber Eats: 4.9

   FoodIndex Score 82.49

   View +Compare ✓Selected
4. #4

   IGAM COFFEE

   Smoothie Bar

   Beachside spot for acai bowls, smoothies, and iced coffee.

   1921 Avenue U · Sheepshead Bay

   Google: 4.8 | Yelp: 4.7 | Uber Eats: —

   FoodIndex Score 80.95

   View +Compare ✓Selected
5. #5

   GOSHT

   Butter-Poached

   Upscale steakhouse with butter-poached cuts and scenic park views.

   3215 Coney Island Ave · Sheepshead Bay

   Google: 4.4 | Yelp: 3.8 | Uber Eats: 4.7

   FoodIndex Score 76.83

   View +Compare ✓Selected
6. #6

   Plaza King Coffee Shop

   Smooth Coffee

   Stylish bakery café with cakes, breads, and smooth coffee drinks.

   5117 Avenue U · Sheepshead Bay

   Google: 4.3 | Yelp: 3.6 | Uber Eats: 4.7

   FoodIndex Score 75.41

   View +Compare ✓Selected
7. #7

   Coffeeko

   Espresso Bar

   Micro-espresso bar pulling intense, high-pressure shots.

   1654 E 15th St · Sheepshead Bay

   Google: 4.7 | Yelp: 5.0 | Uber Eats: 4.5

   FoodIndex Score 73.50

   View +Compare ✓Selected
8. #8

   Drury Coffee

   Cold Brew

   Surf-side café pouring specialty coffee and beachy cold brew.

   1501 Sheepshead Bay Rd · Sheepshead Bay

   Google: 4.8 | Yelp: 4.0 | Uber Eats: —

   FoodIndex Score 72.93

   View +Compare ✓Selected
9. #9

   Ristretto Cafe

   Bold Brew

   Staten Island spot known for energizing, bold coffee drinks.

   3121 Ocean Ave 2nd Fl · Sheepshead Bay

   Google: 4.5 | Yelp: 4.7 | Uber Eats: —

   FoodIndex Score 72.75

   View +Compare ✓Selected
10. #10

    Tete-a-Tete

    Fresh Brew

    Classic small-town style coffee shop with fresh, simple brew.

    2601 E 14th St · Sheepshead Bay

    Google: 4.3 | Yelp: 3.6 | Uber Eats: 4.7

    FoodIndex Score 70.63

    View +Compare ✓Selected
11. #11

    Clemente's Crab House

    Fish Market

    Quick-service fish market with fried platters to go.

    3939 Emmons Ave · Sheepshead Bay

    Google: 4.3 | Yelp: 3.3 | Uber Eats: 4.6

    FoodIndex Score 67.22

    View +Compare ✓Selected
12. #12

    Cento Uno Pizzeria

    Classic Slice

    Brooklyn pizzeria serving traditional Italian pies with fresh ingredients.

    3101 Quentin Rd · Sheepshead Bay

    Google: 4.8 | Yelp: 2.0 | Uber Eats: 4.7

    FoodIndex Score 65.51

    View +Compare ✓Selected

Best Food in Sheepshead Bay

Category rankings for this neighborhood.

Collections in New York City

Amenity and occasion lists for New York City.

Nearby Neighborhoods

All neighborhoods in New York City →

Explore more of New York City

Compare Sheepshead Bay with the wider New York City food rankings and top restaurants.

Explore New York City on FoodIndex →

How we rank restaurants in Sheepshead Bay

FoodIndex Score combines public rating signals so you can compare restaurants in Sheepshead Bay on one scale. Lists update as restaurant data changes. For the full method, see our methodology page.

How FoodIndex rankings work →