Best Pizza in Upper West Side (2026)
1 places ranked using live data from Google, Yelp, Uber Eats & many other platforms
Top Rated Pizza in Upper West Side
Showing 1 of 1 restaurants · Ranked by FoodIndex score
Made In New York
Classic SliceAstoria pizzeria delivering authentic New York-style slices and pies.
421 Amsterdam Ave · Upper West Side
About Upper West Side Pizza
New York is one of the country's great food metros, and Upper West Side's pizza scene mirrors that breadth, from Sicilian squares to late-night New York slices. Whether you're hunting the best pizza in Upper West Side, a fast slice toward Meatpacking District, or a relaxed table in Throgs Neck, you still have real choice without leaving the area.
Every pizza listing we show for Upper West Side uses that same methodology—live data from Google, Yelp, Uber Eats, and related platforms folded into one score—aligned with how we evaluate pizza across New York, just narrowed to this neighborhood.
We're highlighting 1 highly rated pizza options in Upper West Side; behind each name you'll see coverage spanning wood-fired Neapolitan, late-night New York slices, Sicilian squares, Roman pinsa, and more. Scores move when fresh ratings roll in, which keeps the leaderboard honest for return visits.
How FoodIndex Scores Restaurants
Every venue earns a single 0–100 FoodIndex score by combining signals from major platforms—stars, review volume, recency, and consistency—so you can compare places fairly at a glance.
Google Reviews
Aggregate star ratings and review volume from Google Maps.
Yelp Ratings
Weighted scores from Yelp’s review community and elite reviewers.
Uber Eats Data
Delivery ratings, order frequency, and customer satisfaction.
Frequently Asked Questions
Made In New York are considered some of the best pizza spots in Upper West Side based on FoodIndex data. Rankings use signals like rating quality, review volume, recency, and consistency across public platforms, so the top spots reflect places with strong customer feedback.
FoodIndex gives each place a 0–100 score based on public ratings, review counts, recent activity, and consistency across platforms. Places with strong reviews, steady customer feedback, and enough review volume usually rank higher.
No. FoodIndex rankings are not paid placements. The order is based on data signals, not ads, sponsorships, or restaurant promotions.
Use the restaurant list, neighborhood filters, and address details on this page to find pizza near you in Upper West Side. You can also open each restaurant profile to compare ratings, review counts, menu links, and ordering options.
Yes. Ratings, reviews, menus, and restaurant details can change, so FoodIndex rankings may shift as new data comes in. Check back before you choose a place, especially if you are planning a visit, pickup, or delivery.
More in Upper West Side
Best Burgers in Upper West Side
Modern roadside burger chain with Angus beef, crinkle fries, and creamy shakes.
Pizzeria also serving Detroit-style smash burgers with crispy edges.
South Bronx smash burger spot with ultra-crispy, thin patties.
Best Sushi in Upper West Side
Modern UES sushi bar with creative rolls and sleek décor.
Best Tacos in Upper West Side
Neighborhood taqueria serving classic street tacos and tortas.
Upper West Side taqueria with crispy chicken and carnitas tacos.
Queens taco truck serving carnitas and spicy salsa verde.
Staten Island Mexican spot with carne asada and carnitas tacos.
Bayside taco bar with margaritas and loaded tacos.