Best Pizza in New York

Explore the top pizza spots in New York, ranked by FoodIndex — a data-driven score combining reviews from multiple platforms. Updated regularly with 0 restaurants across the city.

JUMP TO THE RANKINGS
Burgers Coffee Sushi Tacos Steaks Seafood Bakery Hot Dogs

We don't currently have rankings for pizza in New York. Check back soon!

How We Chose the Best Pizza in New York

  • We combine ratings from multiple review platforms including Google, Yelp, and UberEats.
  • We weight by number of reviews and rating consistency over time.
  • We focus on places with an active, recent review history.
  • Scores are recalculated regularly as new reviews are published.
  • No restaurant can pay to be listed or ranked higher.
Learn more about FoodIndex →

Explore More New York Rankings

Best Burgers in New York → Best Steaks in New York → Best Seafood in New York → Best Tacos in New York → Best Coffee in New York → Best Sushi in New York →

FAQ

How does FoodIndex decide which pizza restaurants appear on this list?

We start with restaurants in New York that have an active review history, then include places with enough recent reviews and consistent ratings across multiple platforms. Spots with very few or very old reviews usually don't make the cut.

What is the FoodIndex score?

The FoodIndex score is a combined rating that uses reviews from multiple platforms, plus factors like how many reviews a place has and how consistent those reviews are over time. It turns all that data into one number so it's easy to compare pizza spots.

How often are the pizza rankings updated?

Rankings are refreshed regularly based on the latest review data. When new reviews appear or ratings change on the source platforms, FoodIndex scores are recalculated so the list stays current.

Can a restaurant pay to appear higher in the rankings?

No. Restaurants cannot pay to be added to the list or to move up in the rankings. Positions are determined only by data—review scores, volume, and consistency—so the rankings remain independent and fair.

Why is my favorite pizza spot not listed?

Common reasons include: not enough recent reviews, incomplete data across platforms, or the restaurant being new and still building up a review history. As more reliable data becomes available, new places can be added and rankings can change.